From Positivism to Idealism

A Study of the Moral Dimensions of Legality

From Positivism to Idealism Website price:£63.00 (Regular price: £70.00)
  • Sean Coyle, University of Exeter, UK
  • Series : Applied Legal Philosophy
  • Illuminating the idea of legality by a consideration of its moral nature, this book explores the emergence and development of two rival traditions of legal thought (those of 'positivism' and 'idealism') which together define the structure of modern juridical thought. In doing so, it consciously departs from many of the tendencies and working assumptions that define modern legal philosophy. The book examines the shifts in thinking about the rule of law and the wider significance of law, brought about by changing conceptions of the nature of law: from an understanding of law in which the primary focus is on rights, to an articulation of the legal order as a body of deliberately posited rules, and finally to the present understanding of law as a systematic body of rules and principles underpinned by an abiding concern with individual rights. By exposing the historical and metaphysical underpinnings of these theoretical traditions, the book imparts an idea of their limitations and moves beyond the understandings offered within them of the nature of legality.

  • Contents: Preface; Reflection on law's nature; Reason, will and law; Doctrinal scholarship and the science of right; Legal positivism, doctrinal science and statist conceptions of law; The changing face of positivism: from Hobbes to Hart; The limits of legal positivism; Beyond positivism and idealism; Liberal politics and private law;The moral nature of law; Index.

  • About the Author: Sean Coyle is Professor of Jurisprudence, Department of Law at the University of Exeter, UK

  • Reviews: 'With its emphasis on both history and social practices, From Positivism to Idealism offers an important rethinking of legal theory, and a sharp challenge to conventional views. Sean Coyle is one of the most innovative thinkers in legal philosophy today.
    Brian H. Bix, University of Minnesota, USA.

    'Sean Coyle's new work is a bold attempt to reinvestigate and reinvigorate jurisprudence, displaying a combination of imaginative reach and close analytical grip. It is alert to both contemporary disputes and the wider historical tradition. Its great merit is that it uses the latter to criticize the former, hence managing to move beyond the recent limited turf wars.'
    Ross Harrison, King's College, Cambridge

  • Extracts from this title are available to view:

    Full contents list